Reviews Hotel Astor - Florence

3 stelle
Via Maragliano 101, 50144 Florence Map
Prices from € 50
Best Price Guaranteed
Book Now
Hotel Astor

Average Ranking

Good

7.2/10

on 124 surveys

38% of customers would book Hotel Astor again

Average Rating

  • Cleanliness of the Rooms
    7.4
  • Room Comforts and Facilities
    6.4
  • Quality and services of the Hotel
    6.8
  • Staff Assistance
    7.9
  • Restaurant and bar
    6.9
  • Connections to the City
    8.3
  • Surrounding Area
    6.6
  • Accuracy of the website description
    7.3
  • Value for money
    7.5
  • Overall satisfaction
    7.1

Average Ranking

Good

7.2/10

on 124 surveys

38% of customers would book Hotel Astor again

Pietro
Italy Country
October 2012
Family with teenagers
5.4/10
Would you return to this hotel?
No
5.4/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Pio
Italy Country
October 2012
Family with teenagers
Good
7/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Davide
Italy Country
September 2012
Couple more than 35 years old
4/10

Il bagno è angusto con materiali scadenti e senza scarico dell'acqua che straborda dalla doccia.

Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
4/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Claude
France Country
August 2012
Couple more than 35 years old
Good
7.4/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7.4/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Carmen
Canada Country
August 2012
Family with small children
Good
7.8/10

Une partie du toit de la chambre était ouverte et un peu d'eau coulait par là.

Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7.8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Nicola
Italy Country
August 2012
Family with teenagers
Good
7.2/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Good
7.2/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Gulshat
Russia Country
July 2012
Single business traveller
Good
7.2/10
Would you return to this hotel?
No
Good
7.2/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
July 2012
Couple less than 35 years old
Pleasant
6.2/10

Petit déjeuner insuffisant, décevant

Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Pleasant
6.2/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Sergio
Italy Country
July 2012
Couple more than 35 years old
Pleasant
6/10

Albergo tenuto male maniglia del bagno quasi staccata, nessuna asta per ascugamano, personale alla colazione scortese neanche un saluto, cameriera un po' distratta in altro.

Would you return to this hotel?
No
Pleasant
6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
May 2012
Couple less than 35 years old
Good
7.8/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7.8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Nicolò
Italy Country
April 2012
Traveller with friends
Wonderful
9.4/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Wonderful
9.4/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
April 2012
Traveller with friends
Very good
8/10

One thing that I don't like in this hotel, there's no toilet paper and slipper but the staff is kind and very accommodating.

Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Very good
8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Michel
France Country
April 2012
Family with teenagers
Good
7.6/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7.6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Monica
Italy Country
April 2012
Couple less than 35 years old
Good
7/10

La cosa fastidiosa era l'odore di fogne e in alcune camere si sentiva un rumore continuo di un generatore esterno.

Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Stefano
Italy Country
April 2012
Family with teenagers
Good
7.8/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Good
7.8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Gaetano
Italy Country
February 2012
Couple less than 35 years old
Very good
8/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Very good
8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Vincenzo
Italy Country
February 2012
Couple less than 35 years old
Exceptional
9.6/10

Lo consigliamo a tutti per tutti i tipi di soggiorno!

Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Exceptional
9.6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
January 2012
Single business traveller
5.3/10
Would you return to this hotel?
No
5.3/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Davide
Italy Country
October 2011
Couple less than 35 years old
Very good
8.2/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Yes
Very good
8.2/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
October 2011
Traveller with friends
Good
7/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Good
7/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
October 2011
Couple less than 35 years old
Good
7.6/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Good
7.6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
October 2011
Single business traveller
Pleasant
6.6/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Pleasant
6.6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Giorgio
Italy Country
October 2011
Traveller with friends
3.8/10

Il riscaldamento è spento fino al 1 novembre e dunque la stanza risultava fredda. La mattina ci siamo svegliati con i vetri della finestra appannati per la condensa che si ea formata a causa della bassa temperatura (circa 16 gradi). Il bagno aveva tutti isanitari fissati malamente al muro, praticamente mobili. La prima notte abbiamo dovuto sopportare il rumore fastidioso del ventilatore di una stanza accanto, che non ci ha fatto chiudere occhio, senza poter far nulla. La seconda notte ci è stata cambiata stanza, nella quale non si chiudeva la porta, il bagno era nelle medesime condizioni della prima e la temperatura idem.

Scarsa colazione offerta con broches industriali e succhi di frutta fatti con liofiizzati, imbevibili.

Struttura fatiscente.

Per un albergo a 3 stelle e per 3 euro al giorno di imposta di soggiorno (non lo sapevo) da Firenze ci si aspetterebbe qualcosa in più.

Struttura assolutamente sconsigliata.

Would you return to this hotel?
No
3.8/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Anonymous
October 2011
Single business traveller
Very good
8.4/10
Would you return to this hotel?
Unsure
Very good
8.4/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction
Diego
Spain Country
October 2011
4.6/10

El hotel en mi opinión era caro para la calidad que tenía. En mi opinión era lejos del centro, unos 20 minutos andando aunque creo que había autobuses. Lo peor eran las habitaciones, los tabiques eran muy finos se escuchaba todo lo de la habitación de al lado y era muy desagradable. A mi no me gustó. El desayuno bien. En mi opinión el hotel no merece 3 estrellas.

Would you return to this hotel?
No
4.6/10
details
No Answer Very bad Bad Adequate Good Excellent
n.a. 2 4 6 8 10
Cleanliness of the Rooms
Room Comforts and Facilities
Quality and services of the Hotel
Staff Assistance
Restaurant and bar
Connections to the City
Surrounding Area
Accuracy of the website description
Value for money
Overall satisfaction

Additional Hotels Nearby:

View more hotels in Florence »